A wild NFL offseason of potential quarterback motion began out with a bang when the Rams and Lions agreed to commerce their beginning passers in 2021.
Matthew Stafford is headed west to play for Sean McVay in Los Angeles, whereas Jared Goff ships out to Detroit to function beneath new head coach Dan Campbell. The deal will not go into impact till the brand new NFL yr begins on March 17, nevertheless it units an early tone for sweeping QB change throughout the league.
Lions new common supervisor Brad Holmes, who got here from the Rams’ group, reunites with Goff. For McVay and Rams’ common supervisor Les Snead, they get a bit older and higher at QB with the 32-year-old Stafford.
The one distinction is, the Lions racked up different belongings within the swap, whereas it price the Rams rather more than Goff. Here is how the commerce graded out either side:
Matthew Stafford-Jared Goff commerce grades
- QB Matthew Stafford
- QB Jared Goff
- 2021 third-round draft decide
- 2022 first-round draft decide
- 2023 first-round draft decide
The Rams had been eager about having Goff, the primary total decide in 2006, compete with John Wolford for the beginning job in 2021. With that, it made sense to attempt to get out of his contract and go for a bona-fide veteran starter taking part in the perfect soccer of his profession. Stafford makes the Rams a harmful passing crew once more together with his massive arm and weapons comparable to Robert Woods, Cooper Kupp and Van Jefferson. McVay’s teaching will get essentially the most out of Stafford and provides him an opportunity to be a playoff-winning QB, which he by no means has been.
Here is the rub: On paper, Stafford measures increased than Goff in each which method, however his resume is skinny in the case of placing a crew on his again. The Seahawks nonetheless have Russell Wilson, whereas Kyler Murray is a rising chief and famous person within the NFC West. The 49ers additionally might quickly be making a giant QB improve themselves as current NFC champions.
Stafford offers the Rams the next flooring and retains them as a powerful playoff contender, however within the massive image of attempting to get again to the Tremendous Bowl, has an overrated ceiling. The Rams, who do not have a first-round decide once more 2021, gave up two extra over the following two years.
McVay and Snead’s plan of going for it now has had combined outcomes, they usually’re not well-positioned for a looming rebuild within the close to future. Stafford’s contract scenario is extra favorable totally free company flexibility elsewhere, however he additionally has solely two years left on his contract, which implies he isn’t assured to be in LA long-term, both.
The Rams get factors for being aggressive to spice up their contending standing, however get docked for being short-sighted and giving up a bit an excessive amount of.
Take into account Goff because the gravy on this deal as a substitute of the meat: When you’re viewing this commerce as Lions selecting to downgrade from Stafford to Goff, then you might have the unsuitable perspective. As a substitute, Holmes maximized the return for Stafford — a QB and group pairing which did not wish to be collectively anymore — after which some. Goff has been struggling of late for McVay however a change of surroundings might help, and he additionally joins offensive coordinator Anthony Lynn, one other LA import; Lynn did good work with Philip Rivers and Justin Herbert as Chargers head coach.
Goff offers the Lions a viable choice to start out now, tabling having to attain for a QB within the 2021 NFL Draft, not figuring out if Ohio State’s Justin Fields or BYU”s Zach Wilson would nonetheless be accessible at decide No. 7. The Lions determine to re-sign extensive receiver Kenny Golladay for Goff, whereas additionally probably seeking to substitute older free-agent extensive receiver Marvin Jones Jr. Working again D’Andre Swift, tight finish T.J. Hockenson and an underrated offensive line can all assist elevate Goff, too.
Goff is a extra dependent QB than Stafford, by way of each system and personnel. To that finish, the Lions can nonetheless get above-average manufacturing from him in a drop-off from Stafford.
Most significantly, Holmes expanded his choices for 2021 and ensured the Lions choose within the first spherical 5 occasions over the following three years. The brand new GM was properly conscious of his crew needing to decide to a rebuild to get the Lions prepared to leap the Packers, Vikings and Bears in just a few years. Detroit can now speed up its youth motion and stockpile much-needed recent expertise on either side of the ball.
The Rams’ acquisition of Stafford got here at an costly alternative price. The Lions did not need Stafford, acquired their meant excessive picks for the long run and an honest QB choice for the quick time period. The Rams can win solely so many extra video games with Stafford, whereas the Lions can have delight for “successful” the commerce.